Moneyzine
Contents
/Investment Guides /Poison Pill Defense

Poison Pill Defense

Moneyzine Editor
Author: 
Moneyzine Editor
5 mins
September 20th, 2023
Advertiser Disclosure

One of the ways a company can protect itself from a hostile takeover bid is by adopting a poison pill defense. Generally, this term is used to describe several approaches the target company can employ to make the potential acquisition less desirable. In this article, we're going to talk about a strategy that target companies can use to protect themselves from hostile takeovers. As part of that discussion, we're going to provide a definition of the term "poison pill," as well as present some history of the phrase. Since the term is often used to describe one or more of several different strategies, we'll give examples of each approach.

Poison Pills

The term poison pill is defined as any corporate provision, or strategy, that is used by a company to protect itself from a hostile takeover bid. The term originated from the world of espionage, where spies were instructed to swallow a poisonous pill rather than risk capture. The phrase was first used in a business setting by Martin Lipton, of Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen, and Katz. Lipton invented the poison pill defense during a takeover battle in Texas back in 1982. At the time, T. Boone Pickens was trying to acquire General American Oil. Lipton advised the company's Board of Directors to flood the market with new shares of stock. By diluting the stock purchased by Pickens, the company could regain control of its destiny. The strategy was eventually ruled as a legal defense mechanism by the Delaware Supreme Court in 1985, and was legally recognized for the first time in the case of Moran v. Household International.

Poison Pill Provisions

These defensive techniques have evolved over time, and while this strategy may take several forms, the most common structures include:

  • Preferred Stock Plans: this is preferred stock registered with the SEC and paid as a dividend to common shareholders. This preferred stock has an important feature: it is convertible to common stock only after the takeover is completed. This strategy both dilutes the ownership of the acquiring company (which is highly undesirable for the acquirer) as well as increases the cost of the merger.

  • Flip-Over Plans: this allows shareholders to purchase shares of common stock in the new company at a substantial discount after the merger. While this approach is simpler to implement than a preferred stock plan, it does not prevent a company from purchasing a controlling share of the target.

  • Flip-In Plans: this strategy provides shareholders of the target company with the right to purchase additional stock in the target company at substantial discounts. The right to purchase stock occurs before the merger is finalized, and the provision is usually triggered when the acquirer owns greater than a 20% share of the target's stock.

  • Back-End Plans: this approach provides shareholders of the target company with the right to cash or debt securities at a price established by the company's Board of Directors. By doing so, the target company has essentially established an above-market selling price for the company.

  • Poison Puts: this is a bond that allows investors to cash in the security before it matures, if the target company is engaged in a hostile takeover attempt. The poison put places pressure on the acquiring company to raise substantial sums of money to pay off the owners of the puts.

Escape Clauses

When poison pills are put into place by management, they are usually accompanied by an escape clause. The escape clause allows the issuing company to redeem the poison pill via a small payment to the shareholder.

poison pill defense

One of the advantages of the escape clause is that it prevents dilution of ownership if the acquiring company is not viewed as hostile. For example, this can occur when the acquiring company is offering shareholders a substantial premium over the current market price of their stock.

Popularity

An often-cited study conducted by the ISS Governance Research service indicates that 46% of companies in the S&P 500 Index had a poison pill defense in-place at the end of 2005. This is down from the nearly 54% level a year earlier. This reduction appears to be a trend, as the study noted the percentage of companies with such a defense has been declining since 2002, when 60% of all S&P 500 companies had such provisions.

Effectiveness

The rise of the poison pill defense back in 1982 is of no surprise. At that time, corporate raiders such as Carl Icahn and T. Boone Pickens were buying companies, breaking them apart, and selling them off in such a way that additional shareholder value was created. Unfortunately, employees working for these companies, including senior management, often lost their jobs in the process. The fact that this practice can create additional shareholder value calls into question its value, since the management of poorly run companies can hide behind such a defense. On the other hand, poison pills are effective at delaying the speed of any takeover, and can often result in higher premiums paid to shareholders during M&A (merger and acquisition) negotiations.


About the Author - Poison Pill Defense


Explore Investing Further

Trading has never been easier, thanks to the rise of online platforms that enable you to buy and sell various assets at the click of a button. But with so many options available, it can be challenging to decide which platform is right for you.
Looking for a way to avoid swap fees while trading forex?
Below listed are the small reviews of the top 10 ETF brokers available across the United States.
Our top beginner's pick for copy trading is eToro. Read on for more details, plus seven good alternatives.
Swing trading stocks can be a great way for investors to take advantage of short-term stock market movements and gain significant returns. If you're interested in swing trading, the key to success lies in selecting the right stocks to buy and sell quickly for a profit.
The table below lists the best stock picks under $2, listed on public exchanges.
The table below lists the best stock picks under $1, listed both on public and OTC exchanges.
This section will highlight the best EV-trading penny stocks available in the United States.
The demand for sustainable energy has grown rapidly in recent years. This has resulted in increased scrutiny of the automotive market. As a result, the electric vehicle (EV) industry has made significant advancements.
Intelligent Bio Solutions Inc. is a life sciences company, founded in 2016 with headquarters in New York and is engaged in performing diagnostic tests, real-time monitoring, and non-invasive surgery for its patients. The firm has developed a CoV-2 Biosensor, which can be used in RNA virus detection.
Hour Loop was founded in 2013 with headquarters in Redmond, Washington. It’s an online retailer involved in e-commerce in the United States that hit the public markets on Jan 7th of 2022. The company sells home/garden decor, electronic products, kitchenware, and apparel through walmart.com, amazon.com, and hourloop.com.

Related Content

How to Make a Million Dollars in 10 Years
Truthfully, this title should actually be “How to Make a Million Dollars in 10 Years Without Going Into Debt", but that is just getting a little too winded for my liking. It’s true though!
March 26th, 2024
How to Apply Maslow’s Hierarchy to Your Money This Year
You might vaguely remember your psychology teacher talking about Maslow. He pointed at a picture of a triangle as you nodded off in the back of the school room.
March 27th, 2024
How to Tackle Multiple Savings Goals
When there’s only so much money to go around, there are often multiple savings goals competing for your money. Think of the young professional who’d like to get a more reliable car, buy a house, and save for retirement. Or consider the young family that’s saving for college, retirement, and a bigger house.
March 22nd, 2024
The Countdown to Early Retirement: 10 Expenses to Eliminate
Dreaming of waving goodbye to the daily grind five years ahead of schedule? The road to early retirement is paved with more than good intentions; it requires a meticulously crafted strategy with surprising twists. It's not solely about what you should be doing—like diligently saving a portion of your income or investing wisely—but also about what you need to stop doing.
March 22nd, 2024
Biden Or Trump: Who Is Better For The Economy And Stocks?
Yup. This is one of those articles. It's an election year, and here in the U.S., we get to decide which old dude who’s been alive long enough to remember when there were only 48 states in the U.S. will be the leader of the free world.
March 19th, 2024

Contributors

Moneyzine 2024. All Rights Reserved.